From Search to Conversation: How Local Discovery Is Being Rewritten by AI

How has discovery moved beyond Google first thinking?

The era of discovery is no longer confined to Google Search. Andrew Shortland, Founder and CEO of Local SEO Guide, believes the future of visibility lies in conversational platforms such as Reddit, Facebook Groups, and niche forums where real people ask, share, and respond in their natural language. These spaces are shaping the next generation of AI training data. Instead of treating websites as the central hub of marketing, businesses must now think of them as validation layers and trust signals that confirm credibility after conversations have already begun elsewhere.

This shift is driven by how large language models source their understanding of the world. They learn from conversation, not corporate blogs. When people seek recommendations, they turn to authentic voices, not perfectly optimized web pages. Visibility therefore belongs to brands that actively participate in these conversations rather than just publish content about them.

Why customer engagement is becoming the new SEO

Customer engagement has always mattered, but in the AI era it defines discoverability. Visibility now depends on how brands interact across multiple touchpoints where discussions unfold. Instead of chasing traffic, businesses must aim for meaningful visibility by being part of real exchanges, adding value, and earning mentions in spaces that feed AI systems.

The rulebook is simple. Be helpful first, not promotional. When a brand engages with users by answering questions, clarifying doubts, or sharing transparent insights, it naturally builds trust. That trust becomes discoverable data, signaling authority to both people and algorithms.

Are backlinks still relevant in a local first world?

Backlinks remain part of the ranking mix, but their influence has evolved. Shortland’s team studied data across thousands of businesses using SEMrush’s Local Map Rank Tracker and found a counterintuitive pattern. Fewer and higher quality links often correlated with stronger local performance. It is no longer about link volume. It is about link relevance.

For local businesses, prominence now depends on a wider mix of signals such as proximity, reviews, photos, user generated content, and behavioral metrics like driving directions and clicks on Google Business Profiles. Backlinks that come from locally relevant or industry specific domains matter far more than general link building at scale.

How can brands measure visibility across AI platforms?

Analytics for AI led discovery is still catching up. While Google Maps offers visibility metrics, platforms like ChatGPT and Perplexity make attribution harder. Shortland points to tools like Local Falcon and Yext Scout that provide early frameworks for tracking visibility across AI environments. He also suggests setting up custom referral tracking in Google Analytics using regex to capture AI driven traffic.

Right now, ChatGPT stands out as the only AI platform consistently driving measurable referral traffic. The others remain largely opaque, often categorizing traffic as direct. Until tracking becomes standardized, marketers must rely on directional indicators such as visibility shifts, referral tags, and manual lead source surveys.

How should enterprises and small businesses split focus?

The discovery challenge is shared by all, but scale changes the complexity. Enterprise brands must now manage visibility across thousands of listings and citation networks, while small businesses must compete through credibility and human engagement. Both face the same problem of finite resources and the need to be present where their audience spends time.

As Google’s AI overviews grow, traditional local packs are shrinking. Data shows that AI overviews have replaced nearly 15 percent of local pack results, signaling a long term fragmentation of discovery. For both large and small businesses, this means optimizing across more citation sources, testing engagement strategies on multiple forums, and keeping local data updated everywhere.

What skill defines success for marketers in this new landscape?

The single most valuable skill is brand building. Local SEO tactics may evolve, but brand trust will remain the consistent differentiator across every platform, human or AI. The more people search for a brand, talk about it, and associate it with reliability, the stronger its AI and search visibility will become.

Marketers should focus on three fundamentals

1. Build brand recall across forums and communities.
2. Maintain perfect consistency in local data such as name, address, and phone.
3. Create conversation worthy content that solves real problems.

The ability to operationalize brand visibility across conversational ecosystems will define leadership in the years ahead.

‍